Discussion about this post

User's avatar
ebear's avatar

Noam Chomsky pops up a fair bit in that article, which is unfortunate since any attempt to construct a theory of language based on his principles is likely to fail. The basic issue is that he failed to recognize how Kurt Godel's incompleteness theorem applied to linguistics.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6del%27s_incompleteness_theorems

Godel's, as well as Alfred Korzybski's work, was available at the time Chomsky was studying, but he apparently wasn't aware of them, or of the fatal blow Godel's theorem dealt to Russell & Whitehead's program as expressed in 'Principia Mathematica.' The only place I've actually read about this crisis is in Douglas Hofstadter's 1979 work Gödel, Escher, Bach. The rest of academia, save Marshal McLuhan and a few others, seem oblivious to their work, which defined the boundary conditions for what we can actually know with any certainty.

That aside, I also see Chomsky as yet another victim of Expert Syndrome.

https://www.inc.com/suzanne-lucas/forget-imposter-syndrome-its-expert-syndrome-that-should-scare-you.html

In a nutshell, it's the tendency of people who are experts in one field to assume they have competency in others. The house I lived which was designed by a doctor who thought he was an architect is a good example. No less than 9 revisions to the plan until the builder apparently gave up. Now read this and tell me if you don't see it:

https://nationalpost.com/news/world/noam-chomsky-says-the-unvaccinated-should-just-remove-themselves-from-society

The guy displays a stunning lack of knowledge on the subject, not to mention a complete lack of empathy for the people affected by the policies he endorses. He apparently missed a part of his own history where Jews in Nazi Germany were accused of spreading typhus, following a long tradition of such accusations going all the way back to Roman times.

Not that Chomsky is alone in that regard. How often do you hear a public figure of his stature say "I'm sorry, I just don't feel qualified to comment on that issue?" Ironically, the most notorious of cross-disciplinarians, Marshal McLuhan, was himself accused of 'trespassing on other's domains" when he himself pointed directly at that exact problem.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts