Dialectical Warfare for Normies - Lecture 2
How Marxism Manipulates Reality
Thanks to my readers' generosity, all my articles are free to access. Independent journalism, however, requires time and investment. If you found value in this article or any others, please consider sharing or even becoming a paid subscriber, who benefits by joining the conversation in the comments. I want you to know that your support is always gratefully received and will never be forgotten. Please buy me a coffee or as many as you wish.
Lecture 1 • Lecture 2 • Lecture 3 • Lecture 4
How Marxism Manipulates Reality
Stephen Coughlin is a strategist whose deep dives into political warfare are essential reading in think tanks and military circles. His work often focuses on how narratives are crafted and deployed to shape public opinion, influence policy, and control the direction of entire societies. The complexity of the ideas in his presentations might make it tough for those of us outside the Pentagon or Think Tanks to grasp.
This series is designed to bridge that gap. The purpose of these posts is to take Coughlin’s vital insights and make them more accessible to “Normies”— everyday people who aren’t professional analysts but who still want to understand how the world really works. By simplifying and breaking down these concepts, we aim to empower you with the knowledge to see through the spin and recognize the strategies at play in today’s political and social battles.
Across four posts, we’ll boil down Coughlin’s critical ideas in clear, straightforward language, focusing on how these concepts affect your life and the world around you. Whether you’re new to these topics or looking for a better understanding, this series will give you the tools to navigate the complex landscape of modern political warfare.
🧩 The Hegelian Dialectic in Cultural Transformation
Hegel’s concept of “Aufheben” is the foundation of Marxist thought. “Aufheben” simultaneously means to preserve and to destroy, allowing something to be both itself and its opposite at the same time. This idea is used to manipulate reality, breaking down traditional ideas and replacing them with new ones. The Hegelian dialectic uses contradictions to push society toward continuous change, rather than maintaining stability.
🔄 How Contradictions Are Used to Shape Society
Marxist thinkers apply Hegelian dialectics by using contradictions to drive social change. The Frankfurt School, an intellectual group in Germany, took this idea and applied it to culture. Their goal was to weaken and eventually dismantle traditional Western culture. This process involves creating conflicts between opposing ideas and then resolving them in a way that moves society in a new direction. The aim is to keep society in a state of constant change, where old values are continuously replaced with new ones.
🧱 Lenin’s Application of Hegelian Logic
Lenin, a key Marxist leader, adopted Hegelian dialectics to advance Marxist revolution. Lenin rejected classical logic, which is based on clear, consistent rules, and instead embraced contradictions as a tool for change. In his Philosophical Notebooks, Lenin documented how he applied Hegelian logic to Marxist strategy, using it to manipulate situations and achieve revolutionary goals. By using contradictions, Lenin could justify any action, even if it seemed to go against earlier principles.
🇨🇳 Mao’s Revolutionary Strategy
Yale’s Mao Zedong used Hegelian dialectics to lead the Chinese revolution. In his work On Contradiction, Mao explained how embracing contradictions is essential for revolutionary success. Mao applied this strategy to overthrow the old order in China and establish a new communist state. By constantly shifting the focus and creating new conflicts, Mao was able to maintain control and push society toward his vision of continuous revolution.
🚫 The Attack on Classical Logic
Hegelian dialectics deliberately violate classical logic, which states that something cannot be both itself and its opposite at the same time. By rejecting this principle, Marxist thinkers use contradictions to create confusion and manipulate reality. This strategy undermines traditional ways of thinking and replaces them with a worldview where contradictions are not only accepted but are seen as necessary for progress.
🎭 Cancel Culture as a Modern Application
Cancel culture operates as a modern form of “Aufheben.” It seeks to preserve certain aspects of culture while destroying others, often targeting traditional values and norms. This dual process continues the Frankfurt School’s mission to dismantle Western culture by using contradictions to reshape societal values. Cancel culture is part of a broader strategy to destabilize and transform society through continuous conflict and change.
🌀 Mysticism in Hegelian Dialectics
Hegelian dialectics are inherently mystical, using speculative ideas that go beyond traditional logic. Marxist leaders, despite publicly mocking mysticism, fully adopted Hegel’s approach because it allowed them to manipulate reality in ways that classical logic could not. This mystical aspect makes Marxist ideology powerful, as it seduces and controls both followers and opponents by creating an alternate reality where contradictions drive progress.
✊ Contradiction as a Tool for Revolution
Contradictions are not flaws in Marxist theory but are essential tools for achieving revolutionary change. By embracing contradictions, Marxist thinkers can continuously create conflicts that push society toward their desired outcomes. This method, rooted in Hegelian dialectics, views the synthesis of opposing ideas as necessary for progress and societal transformation. The deliberate use of contradictions is a powerful way to destabilize and reshape society.
🧠 Dialectical Manipulation in Science and Culture
Dialectical manipulation extends into science and culture, where ideas like “Schrödinger’s cat” illustrate how contradictions are used to challenge traditional logic. This approach creates confusion and undermines established ways of thinking, replacing them with a dialectical worldview that supports Marxist objectives. The goal is to erode classical reasoning and replace it with a system where contradictions are used to control and influence how people think and act. [16:27]
📖 Glossary of Terms
Aufheben - “Aufheben” is a crucial concept from Hegelian philosophy that means both “to preserve” and “to destroy” simultaneously. This duality is foundational in Marxist dialectics, where it is used to manipulate reality by resolving contradictions in a way that advances ideological objectives. 01:58
Hegelian Dialectic - The Hegelian dialectic is a process of conflict and resolution involving a thesis, antithesis, and synthesis. This framework drives the continuous change and transformation of ideas, making it a core tool in Marxist strategy for challenging and reshaping societal values. 01:12
Law of Non-Contradiction - The law of non-contradiction is a classical principle of logic that states something cannot be both itself and its opposite at the same time. Marxist dialectics deliberately violate this law to create contradictions that can be manipulated to produce ideological change. 05:43
Praxis - Praxis refers to the practical application of theoretical concepts, particularly in Marxist theory, where it signifies the implementation of revolutionary ideas into real-world actions. Praxis is essential for transforming ideological goals into tangible societal changes. 07:24
Dialectical Event - A dialectical event occurs when conflicting ideas or forces interact, leading to a synthesis that pushes forward a specific ideological agenda. These events are pivotal in Marxist strategy for orchestrating and guiding societal transformation. 03:07
Cultural Subversion - Cultural subversion is the systematic undermining and replacement of a society’s cultural norms and values with those that align with Marxist ideology. This is achieved through continuous ideological pressure and infiltration of cultural institutions such as education, media, and religion. 11:35
Pseudo-Reality - A pseudo-reality is a fabricated narrative or construct imposed on society, replacing the existing worldview with an ideologically driven one. This process is facilitated through the Dialogue/Praxis Process, eventually leading to the widespread acceptance of this new, distorted reality as the norm. 31:45
Science of Understanding - The Science of Understanding refers to the traditional scientific method based on observed evidence, objective observation, and rational inquiry. This approach has been the foundation of Western scientific progress, focusing on the discovery and explanation of truths about the natural world through evidence-based research. 30:26
Science of Reason - The Science of Reason in Marxist thought diverges from traditional science, adopting a pseudo-scientific approach that prioritizes ideological goals over observed evidence. This method serves as a tool to subvert and replace established cultural and scientific norms, imposing an alternate version of reality through authoritative control. 30:26
Hegelian Metaphysic - The Hegelian Metaphysic involves the philosophical belief that reality is shaped by the dialectical process of conflict and resolution. This concept is applied in Marxist strategy to manipulate societal structures, using conflict to drive change toward a predetermined ideological outcome. 20:52
Interfaith Movement - The interfaith movement is identified as a key avenue for Marxist infiltration. Through interfaith dialogue, Marxist principles are introduced into religious institutions under the guise of promoting unity among different faiths, ultimately leading to the gradual subversion of traditional religious values. 34:16
Bibliography
The Phenomenology of Spirit, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel - This foundational work introduces the concept of “Aufheben,” a process that simultaneously preserves and destroys, which is central to Hegelian dialectics. Understanding “Aufheben” is crucial for grasping the manipulative strategies at the core of Marxist ideology, as it reveals how contradictions are used to advance ideological objectives. [01:58]
Science of Logic, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel - This book elaborates on the speculative nature of Hegel’s dialectical method, particularly through terms like “Aufheben.” The text outlines how Hegelian dialectics intentionally violate classical logic, such as the law of non-contradiction, making it a vital tool for Marxist thinkers to undermine traditional structures of reasoning and identity. [01:58]
On Contradiction, Mao Zedong - This work applies Hegelian dialectics within the context of the Chinese revolution, using the principle of contradiction as a method to drive revolutionary change. The text serves as a practical guide for implementing Marxist-Leninist principles, showing how embracing and manipulating contradictions can be an effective strategy for achieving political and ideological dominance. [09:11]
Philosophical Notebooks (Volume 38), Vladimir Lenin - In these notebooks, Lenin engages deeply with Hegel’s works, rejecting classical logic in favor of dialectical reasoning. This volume is critical for understanding how Lenin incorporated Hegelian dialectics into Marxist theory, establishing a framework that would become central to revolutionary Marxist strategies. [08:29]
Encyclopedia of the Philosophical Sciences, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel - This comprehensive work presents Hegel’s dialectical philosophy as inherently mystical, despite its later adoption by Marxist theorists who publicly derided mysticism. The text is fundamental to understanding how Hegel’s speculative and mystical ideas were absorbed into Marxist ideology, providing a deeper layer of manipulation and control. [01:58]